Who should decide when an emergency is over? That question is increasing tension between Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf and the state’s GOP. And now the voters get to weigh in. NBC10’s Lauren Mayk explains.
What to Know
- The pandemic power struggle that's raged between Pennsylvania’s Democratic governor and its Republican-led Legislature over the year plus of COVID-19 will land on voters’ laps on May 18.
- It's taking the form of two proposed constitutional amendments to limit the length of disaster emergencies.
- Even if you're not registered with a political party, you can cast a vote on the ballot questions.
The head of the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency on Thursday said two ballot questions for voters to consider in the May 18 election could have a "detrimental impact on the state's ability to respond to future disasters and emergencies."
PEMA Director Randy Padfield asked voters to cast a "no" for both of the questions. All registered voters in Pennsylvania, regardless of political party affiliation, are able to vote on the ballot questions on Election Day.
Padfield's public plea is the latest salvo in a back-and-forth battle between Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf's administration and the Republican-controlled legislature.
Get top local stories in Philly delivered to you every morning. Sign up for NBC Philadelphia's News Headlines newsletter.
The two ballot questions would amend the state constitution to shift authority over the length of emergency declarations from governors to lawmakers.
The feud between the Democrat-run executive branch and the Republican leadership in the General Assembly began in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic last year. The political bickering is over the governor's use of the emergency declaration to restrict and shut down businesses, order citizens to adhere to health mandates and put moratoriums on foreclosures and evictions for months.
"An emergency declaration is meant to give the executive branch the power to triage a crisis, not a vehicle for the governor to enact, amend and suspend laws and regulations for an excessive period of time," Senate GOP caucus spokeswoman Erica Clayton Wright said last month.
Padfield, during his press conference, said voters should not weigh the ballot questions with just the coronavirus pandemic in mind.
"The impact of these amendments should not be viewed solely through the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, as they have far-reaching impacts for all future disasters regardless of the cause," he said.
He said that executive oversight of emergency powers is "key to respond rapidly" after a disaster or crisis occurs.
Republican lawmakers have also accused Wolf's administration of purposely writing the questions with wording designed to scare voters into rejecting them. But that is not something that happens much, if at all.
A majority of Pennsylvania voters have not rejected a ballot question in decades, according to Ballotpedia. Between 1995 and 2019, 17 of 17 ballot questions have been approved by voters, according to the online election portal.
“We respect the voters, we think they'll see through it, they’ll understand it and we hope to do our best to educate them on it,” Senate President Pro Tempore Jake Corman, R-Centre said.
Wolf's office said the wording in the ballot questions “fairly, accurately and clearly apprise the voter of the issue to be voted on.”
Courts have nearly unanimously backed Wolf’s use of emergency powers to impose social-distancing restrictions, close buildings or limit business activity during the pandemic. Wolf’s administration maintains that the proposed amendments will not affect those powers because they rest on the state’s Disease Prevention and Control Act.
Wolf opposed the questions, but governors have no power to prevent proposals to amend the constitution from going on the ballot for voters to consider.
Here is the exact wording of the two questions regarding the emergency powers in the constitution, along with an explanation in plain terms provided by the League of Women Voters.
Pennsylvania Ballot Question #1
Shall the Pennsylvania Constitution be amended to change existing law and increase the power of the General Assembly to unilaterally terminate or extend a disaster emergency declaration—and the powers of Commonwealth agencies to address the disaster regardless of its severity pursuant to that declaration—through passing a concurrent resolution by simple majority, thereby removing the existing check and balance of presenting a resolution to the Governor for approval or disapproval?
WHAT THIS MEANS (courtesy of the League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania)
- If you vote YES, you agree to give the Legislature, by a simple majority vote, the sole power to take away the Governor’s existing authority to make disaster emergency declarations and coordinate with relevant Pennsylvania agencies.
- If you vote NO, you disagree with giving the Legislature, by a simple majority vote, the sole power to take away the Governor’s existing authority to make disaster emergency declarations and coordinate with relevant Pennsylvania agencies.
Pennsylvania Ballot Question #2
Shall the Pennsylvania Constitution be amended to change existing law so that: a disaster emergency declaration will expire automatically after 21 days, regardless of the severity of the emergency, unless the General Assembly takes action to extend the disaster emergency; the Governor may not declare a new disaster emergency to respond to the dangers facing the Commonwealth unless the General Assembly passes a concurrent resolution; the General Assembly enacts new laws for disaster management?
WHAT THIS MEANS (courtesy of the League of Women's Voters of Pennsylvania)
- If you vote Yes, you agree to change existing law to limit any Governor’s disaster emergency declaration - no matter the severity - to 21 days (from 90), unless, and until, the Legislature votes by a simple majority to extend the disaster emergency declaration; and take away the Governor’s authority to manage new emergency and disasters situations.
- If you vote No, you disagree with changing the existing law that provides any Governor with the power to issue emergency declarations without a 21-day limitation or a simple majority vote by the Legislature; and any Governor retains authority to act in emergency and disaster situations.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
